Print this page

Blog: Quality! Not Quantity!

Sep 29, 2010 | By Andrea Pascual

This past summer, I was quite irritated when the topic of immigration was brought to the nation’s attention after the state of Arizona attempted to pass a senseless bill (S1070) that would allow local authorities the right to question people they suspect are undocumented. Recently, many communities have been bombarded with even more Border Patrol agents than the previous years. The government keeps putting more money towards security, but are more officers really necessary? Do we really need to keep spending more money on border control, or is just a way to avoid fixing our immigration system?

This past Tuesday, September 28, I attended a congressional briefing entitled “From Quantity to Quality”, on border and community security by the Border Network for Human Rights (BNHR). The message was clear, YES, we need enforcement but, NO, we do not need more patrol officers.

BNHR started their research by conducted a security poll of residents who lived at the border to find out how safe they felt in their neighborhoods. The Arizona Governor, Jan Brewer, was quoted stating that the border was full of “murder, terror and mayhem”. These negative remarks make the rest of the population view the border as barren and lawless when in fact it’s the complete opposite. When asked if they felt safe walking and driving in their neighborhoods, close to 90% of residents responded yes. My own aunt lives out there and she have never complained. Astonishingly, the government continues to think we need more security when what we really need is to reform our current enforcement policies.

There are two agencies along the U.S.-Mexico border: Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and Customs and Border Protection (CBP). With the FY2011 budget of $56.3 billion, there are around 18,500 Border Patrol Agents, 5,600 U.S. Customs Officers and 7,500 ICE Agents. Back in August, Congress approved adding an additional 1,000 Border Patrol Agents. One of the speakers explained that with that many agents, there are 9.4 agents per linear mile of the border (they can wave to each other)!

With the amount of officers securing the border there is a lack of accountability and an abuse of civil rights and liberties. Consequences highlighted were the lack of adequate training and illegal search and seizures. Another interesting point, ICE’s main priority is removing dangerous criminals from our country, but because of their ineffectiveness as of August, less than 10%of th